Wondering if some friendly forum folks can help me figure out which GP key items have value on Nasomi?

It's clear some of them have no use, as some items crafted with certain GP items do not appear to have ever been sold on the AH. Gold Ensorcellment, as one example. Perhaps they are out of era, or just some of the recipes or out of era... either way, I'm just looking for a list of which ones have SOME value. Maybe this list would then help out other players.

I've filled in what my best guesses are based on checking the AH. Feel free to correct me or help with the missing ones and I'll update.

Alchemy

1. Anima Synthesis - Animas for Purification/Ensorcellments
2. Alchemic Purification - Hallowed Water
3. Alchemic Ensorcellment - No Value
4. Iatrochemistry - Useless until PUP is fixed
5. Concoction - Situationally useful (Hi-Ether Drops)
6. Trituration - Big Time Saver

Bonecraft

1. Bone Purification - Reraise Hairpin
2. Bone Ensorcellment - No Value

Clothcraft

1. Cloth Purification - Blink Band
2. Cloth Ensorcellment - No Value
3. Spinning - Big Time Saver

Cooking

1. Patissier - Various recipes
2. Noodle Kneading - Various Pasta recipes
3. Raw Fish Handling - Various Sushi recipes
4. Stewpot Mastery - No Valuable recipes

Goldsmithing

1. Gold Purification - Reraise Earring
2. Gold Ensorcellment - No Value
3. Clockmaking - Useless until PUP is fixed

Leathercrafting

1. Leather Purification - Situational
2. Leather Ensorcellment - High-Breath Mantle

Smithing

1. Metal Purification - Light Steel (NIN af)
2. Metal Ensorcellment - No Value

Woodworking

1. Wood Purification - No Value
2. Wood Ensorcellment - Warp Cudgel
3. Lumberjack - Big Time Saver
4. Boltmaker - No Value (can't HQ)

Also, could someone explain the AH history on Warp Cudgel and Reraise Hairpin? Does the AH automatically give that player those items and money back after listing them?

Thanks in advance.

Leather Ensorcellment is required for High-Breath Mantle, which can be nice in some situations. Cloth Purification is needed for Blink Band, which is, again, situational. Cloth Enscorcellment is useless I believe. Boltmaker for Woodworking is also garbage because it removes the benefits of HQ.

Thanks Epyon... updated the post.

Anyone know if Leather Purification or Wood Purification are also dead weight?

The wood one is garbage, the leather one can create a few extremely situational STAT+10 enchanted belts, with the standout being the Haste Belt. http://ffxiclopedia.wikia.com/wiki/Haste_Belt

Do the fishing ones do anything? There's a belt that gives support but I don't know what support does

_________________
this was funnier before everyone copied me

It probably goes without saying, but for completeness' sake of your list, put Iatochemistry down as useless for Alchemy until PUP is fixed.

Also on the topic of Alchemy: Concoction is very situationally useful, and only for Hi-Ether drops. 45 MP per dose, stackable to 12 in 1 inventory slot, and medication effect for 5min only really leaves room for use in specific scenarios:
Can help get off a last-ditch cure or sleep/bind,
or perhaps a self-refresh if you ran out of MP and convert is down, etc.

Thanks Vavaud, updated Alchemy. Also put Clockmaking down as useless until PUP is fixed.

As for most of the "crystal-saving" abilities (Chainwork/Fletching/Tanning/etc) I left those off the list since the money/time they save hardly seem worth the GP spent. I suppose some may be worth it, though.

Alchemy : you missed the most useful anima synthesis, basis for all the purification/ensorcelement KIs.

Smithing : metal purification is useful for at least 1 thing : http://ffxiclopedia.wikia.com/wiki/Light_Steel used in most NIN af upgrades.

You missed the best two, CC spinning, and WW Lumberjack, 10k each. Saves you sooooooo much time.

_________________
啦體恩的雨水主要下降在其原野中
Making gil starting out!
Nasomi troubleshooting!