I don't remember in retail the Guild Point items ever requiring the HQ. I've seen it a couple of times before, and now today's Smithing item is Breastplate +1, which has just a handful of sales in the history of the server. I could make it, but the NQ is a loss and I'm only tier 1.

Is this - the GP item being only the HQ - intentional, and if so why?

the clothcraft guild, even when it's asking for an HQ, still accepts the NQ.

_________________

Thanks for the reply. I'll try, but I remember that the Smithing guild previously asked for a bronze rod +1, and would not accept the NQ.

The guild did not accept the NQ. Fortunately I got lucky and one of the 3 breastplates I made was an HQ, so I turned that in instead.

Yes GP items are occasionally glitchy like that. GS asked me for Beetle Earring +1

That's weird. I've almost always turned in the NQ item, when asked for an HQ, and never had an issue.. but I've only done it with CC. As recently as yesterday, when the item was a Heko Obi +1 and I was too cheap to spend 15k each on them so I bought a ton of NQs and turned them in.

_________________

I’ve seen one instance with a friend where the guild was requesting something completely off the wall, like the SCH AF2 accessory or something (which, if I had to guess, was some itemID mix-up or something and it actually wants something else).
Wish I had all the details saved so I could send to Nas It was back to a “normal” item the next day

_________________
Armaddon: Mordion Gaol Decorator Lv75

i've got one, if you're on before 11PM CST i can trade it to ya

_________________

Stevesy - thanks, but as I said, I happened to HQ one, so I turned that in. The remaining 800 GP to cap for the day I let go.