so I am having the same issue as a player in this thread: viewtopic.php?f=7&t=6704&p=32152&hilit=Guild+Points#p31935
...except with the Fishing Guild instead...

Tried waiting days, weeks, tried at different levels, tried different fish....
The only time I was able to get points was the very first time I tried ~2200 points
Every time after that it has never worked...

Looks like Nas had to step in to fix it for the other person.
Am i just f'd unless nasomi sees?  

uh, basically yea you f'd i've been unable to use my bonecraft GP for a year on my alt. i basically just stopped leveling it.

_________________
Caoimhe - 75 nin pld war blm drk brd drg sam thf cor mnk
Still a nub