Ukko wrote:
There's like a hundred small things wrong with this.
"Everytime you entered the staff market."
I'm not sure what you mean by that, I've had staffs stocked 95% of the time since I hit 106, so I've only... entered... once. As for raising price on ores, no. I've made a very conscious effort to not push ore prices up, anytime I do it's only when there's 10-20+ ores listed above current prices, the ROI spread has room for it, and even then it's a 5-10k push.
This is false, as cookingkitty began selling hq staves late summer/early fall when the prices were still absurd following the crafting change last may. Cookingkitty's bazaar dissapeared for a couple months, maybe you were on vacation or something, idk. Then cookingkitty sadly returns to undercut again, but luckily your gsm wasnt leveled, so you were quickly cut out by bead prices being too high. But sadly for us, you then leveled gsm and hopped right back in, a THIRD time. All three times you raised prices on ore and undercut prices on staves, trying to take market share, make friends with miners, and push others out to make room for yourself.
Ukko wrote:
"You had a chance to match prices in bazaars, but chose not to."
Um, no, when I first entered most sellers systematically undercut me, and so I did the same, as is the only way to get any sales. For a good 3 months now we've all been mostly matching eachother to a tee.
This is complete bullshit, lol. The established crafters that had been pricing matching for years, were the ones to undercut you first? Not you, the fresh new 106 trying enter the market and make their money back as fast as possible. Riiiiiiiiight. Feter and I have been pricing matching for years, but obviously the constantly repeating meme on this server of new crafter entering markets and undercutting just didnt happen in your case.
Ukko wrote:
"... you then began offering the miners more than the AH for ore, causing the supply of ore to exceed the demand for staves."
Which is perfectly fine in a market where there are only 4 active people who can make staffs, should they talk and exercise a little self-control. In fact it would be a good thing, no longer bottlenecking sales by material supply but rather by the number of buyers around.
It's actually not fine, as there are 20 some wws that make staves here and there, and the price of ore is how the supply of ore entering the market is managed. You just wanted to monopolize as much of the supply as you could. Your prices when youre the only person selling an item are absolutely stupid high.
Ukko wrote:
"Then you thought it would be a good idea to list multiple staves in your bazaar, prompting others to have to do the same."
Perhaps I'm missing something but I don't see how this affects anything, or why me listing multiple would make others want to. I was making sure I had a night's worth of staffs stocked when I went to sleep, seems reasonable.
Because when customers see you have plenty of stock, they wont be in a hurry to buy, and will generally not buy, but send you tells asking for deals instead. Which just lowers the overall price of the items as the crafters that arent getting tells lower their prices to get sales. When customers see you have multiple of an item, you stand out better on the bazaar page. It's like how you stood front and center in lower jeuno when people came from the moghouse, youre just an aggressive advertiser and marketer of yourself. Or when you moved yourself directly in front of me, but not quite close enough to the AH to buy, that was actually "cute". It's pretty simple that getting out advertised and out marketed will often result in a loss of business, especially when there is no distinction in our products, because theyre identical video game pixels.
Ukko wrote:
"I dont really agree with crafters colluding in tells and price fixing, like you and camper were doing, so Im never going to respond to those "collaboration" tells."
This is kinda cute, because here you're clearly trying to take some sort of moral high ground while the whole reason you're upset with me is because you're not profiting enough from selling staffs to players. You can either take the 'profiting is a given' angle or 'profiting is wrong' angle, but you don't get to have it both ways.
Yeah I am. Price is something that manages supply of an item. It's easy to find an equilibrium where everyone is happy, if people simply compete for ore at good prices and match staff prices at good prices. But instead you enter the market butchering said equilibrium. Even if I was open to price fixing, I still wouldnt negotiate with a terrorist.
Ukko wrote:
"It's simple to change a price in your bazaar, and if everytime you do it, it's slightly lower than mine, then the market will be crashed."
There are 2 instances when I lower prices in my bazaar below others. 1) When they've just done the same to me. 2) When the AH prices have been undercut enough that the bazaar listing is now higher than the auction house listing. Both of these seem reasonable to me.
Yes, you finally started following those rules in the last couple of months after you saw what you did to the staff market.
Anything else I can clear up?